The core trade-off
Every pound you use to pay off debt early saves you interest at your loan rate. Every pound you invest earns a return at your investment rate. The question is: which rate is higher?
Pay off debt if: Loan rate > Expected investment return
Paying off a 22% credit card is a guaranteed 22% return. No investment reliably beats that. Paying off a 3% mortgage when you expect 7% investment returns is a different calculation entirely.
The break-even rate
The break-even rate is the investment return at which investing and paying off debt produce the same financial outcome. If your expected return is above the break-even rate, invest. If below, pay off debt.
| Debt type | Typical rate | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card | 20–30% | Always pay off first |
| Personal loan | 6–15% | Usually pay off first |
| Car finance | 5–10% | Borderline — model it |
| Student loan (UK Plan 2) | RPI + 3% | Often invest instead |
| Mortgage | 3–6% | Often invest instead |
Why the comparison is not purely mathematical
Even when investing wins mathematically, paying off debt has real non-financial benefits:
- Guaranteed return. Paying off a 7% loan is a guaranteed 7% return. Investment returns are uncertain — markets can fall.
- Reduced risk. Debt is a liability. Eliminating it reduces your financial vulnerability to job loss or income shocks.
- Psychological freedom. Many people report significant stress relief from being debt-free, which has real value even if it does not show up in a spreadsheet.
- Improved cash flow. Once debt is cleared, the freed monthly payment can be invested — often producing a better long-term outcome than investing while carrying debt.
The scenario that almost always wins: employer pension match
There is one exception to the debt-first rule that is almost universal: always capture your employer pension match before paying extra on any debt.
An employer match is an instant 50–100% return on your contribution. No debt interest rate comes close to that. Even a 22% credit card should not take priority over a 100% employer match.
The optimal order: (1) capture full employer pension match, (2) build a small emergency fund, (3) pay off high-interest debt, (4) invest remaining surplus.
How the calculator models both scenarios
The Debt vs Invest Calculator runs two parallel scenarios over your chosen time horizon and compares the net worth outcome of each:
- Pay off debt scenario: your extra payment accelerates debt payoff. Once the debt is cleared, the freed payment is invested for the remainder of the period.
- Invest scenario: your extra payment goes straight into investments each month while you continue making minimum debt payments.
- Net worth comparison: at the end of the period, total portfolio value minus remaining debt is compared for each scenario.
The key insight: the pay-off-debt scenario often catches up and overtakes the invest scenario once the debt is cleared and the full payment is redirected to investing.
A practical framework
| Debt rate | Recommended action |
|---|---|
| Above 10% | Pay off debt first. The guaranteed saving beats expected investment returns on a risk-adjusted basis. |
| 7–10% | Borderline. Model your specific scenario. Consider splitting extra cash 50/50. |
| Below 7% | Investing likely wins mathematically. But factor in risk tolerance and psychological value of being debt-free. |
| Any rate | Always capture full employer pension match first. |
Frequently asked questions
Should I pay off my mortgage or invest?
At current mortgage rates (4–6%), this is genuinely borderline. Historically, global equities have returned 7–10% annually, suggesting investing wins mathematically. But mortgage overpayments are risk-free. Many people split the difference — overpay the mortgage modestly while also investing.
Does this calculation change with tax?
Yes. Investment returns inside an ISA or pension are tax-free, which improves the case for investing. Debt interest is not tax-deductible for most personal borrowing in the UK. Factor in your tax situation when modelling.
What about UK student loans?
UK student loans (Plan 2) are income-contingent and written off after 30 years. For most borrowers, overpaying is not recommended — the effective interest rate and repayment mechanics make investing a better use of surplus cash. Check your specific plan terms.