Loans & Debt Management

Debt vs Invest Calculator

Got spare cash each month? Find out whether you are better off paying down debt early or investing — and by exactly how much.

£
%
£
£
%
yrs

Pay off debt

Extra goes to loan

Debt cleared in—
Interest saved—
Net worth gain—

Invest instead

Extra goes to portfolio

Portfolio value—
Extra interest paid—
Net worth gain—

Difference after 10 years

—

How the calculator works

The calculator models two parallel scenarios over your chosen time horizon and compares the net worth outcome of each.

  1. 1
    Pay off debt scenario — your extra payment accelerates debt payoff. Once the debt is cleared, the freed-up payment is invested for the remainder of the period.
  2. 2
    Invest scenario — your extra payment goes straight into investments each month while you continue making minimum debt payments.
  3. 3
    Net worth comparison — at the end of the period, we compare total portfolio value minus remaining debt for each scenario.

Frequently asked questions

When is paying off debt better than investing?

When your debt interest rate is higher than your expected investment return. For example, a 22% credit card rate is almost impossible to beat with investments. Any debt above 7-8% is generally worth prioritising over investing.

When is investing better than paying off debt?

When your debt rate is low and your expected investment return is higher. A 3% mortgage vs a 7% expected stock market return means investing likely wins mathematically. However, this ignores the psychological value of being debt-free.

Should I always do one or the other?

Not necessarily. A balanced approach — splitting extra cash between debt repayment and investing — is often sensible. Always prioritise high-interest debt first, and always capture any employer pension match before paying extra on low-rate debt.

Does this account for tax on investments?

No — the calculator uses gross returns. In practice, tax-advantaged accounts (ISAs, pensions) can shelter investment gains. Factor in your personal tax situation when making the final decision.