What is a Monte Carlo simulation?

A Monte Carlo simulation runs thousands of randomised scenarios to model the range of possible outcomes for a given plan. In retirement planning, it generates thousands of different sequences of annual investment returns — some good, some terrible, most somewhere in between — and counts how many result in your pot lasting the full retirement period.

The output is a success rate: the percentage of simulated retirements where your money did not run out. A 90% success rate means your plan worked in 900 out of 1,000 simulated futures.

Why fixed-return calculators are not enough

A standard retirement calculator assumes the same return every year — say, 6% annually. In reality, markets are volatile. Some years return 20%, others lose 30%. The sequence of those returns matters enormously, especially in the early years of retirement.

Good sequence

Strong returns in years 1–5. Portfolio grows before withdrawals take effect. Pot lasts 35+ years.

Bad sequence

Market crash in years 1–3. Forced to sell at low prices to fund withdrawals. Pot depleted by year 22.

Both scenarios have the same average return. A fixed-return calculator would show identical results. Monte Carlo shows the difference.

How the simulation works

Each simulated year, a random annual return is drawn from a normal distribution centred on your expected return with your specified standard deviation (volatility). This produces a realistic spread of outcomes — mostly near the average, with occasional extreme years in both directions.

Return(year) = Normal(μ = r, σ = volatility)

μExpected annual return (e.g. 6%)
σStandard deviation / volatility (e.g. 12%)

After each year, the withdrawal is subtracted and the remaining balance grows (or shrinks) by that year's random return. The simulation runs for the full retirement duration. If the balance reaches zero before the end, that scenario is a failure.

What success rate should you target?

Most financial planners target a 90% success rate as the threshold for a robust retirement plan. Here is how to interpret different success rates:

Success rateInterpretationAction
95–100%Very conservative — likely leaving money unspentConsider increasing withdrawals
85–94%Robust — comfortable margin of safetyPlan is solid
75–84%Acceptable — some risk of shortfallConsider small adjustments
Below 75%High risk — significant chance of running outReduce withdrawals or increase pot

A 100% success rate is not the goal — it usually means you are being overly conservative and will die with a large unspent portfolio. 85–95% is the sweet spot for most people.

Sequence of returns risk: the central challenge

Sequence of returns risk is the danger that poor investment returns early in retirement permanently damage your portfolio. It is the most important risk in retirement planning — and the one most often ignored.

Here is why it matters so much: when you are withdrawing from a portfolio, a loss early on forces you to sell more units to fund the same withdrawal. Those units are then not available to benefit from the eventual recovery.

The most effective mitigation is a cash buffer of 1–2 years of expenses. During a market downturn, draw from cash rather than selling investments at depressed prices. This gives your portfolio time to recover.

Choosing the right inputs

The quality of a Monte Carlo simulation depends on realistic inputs. Here are sensible defaults:

InputConservativeModerateAggressive
Expected return5%6–7%8–9%
Volatility (std dev)8–10%11–14%15–18%
Retirement duration35 years30 years25 years
Withdrawal rate3–3.5%4%4.5–5%

A 60/40 portfolio (60% equities, 40% bonds) typically has a long-run return of around 6% with a standard deviation of 10–12%. A 100% equity portfolio might use 7–8% return with 15–17% volatility.

Monte Carlo vs the 4% rule

The 4% rule (from the Trinity Study) was itself derived from a form of historical simulation — testing withdrawal rates against every 30-year period in US market history. Monte Carlo extends this by generating synthetic scenarios beyond historical data.

4% rule

Simple, well-researched, widely understood. Based on historical US data. Does not account for current valuations or non-US markets.

Monte Carlo

Models a wider range of scenarios including those not seen historically. More flexible inputs. Shows probability distribution, not just a pass/fail.

Use both. The 4% rule gives you a quick sanity check. Monte Carlo gives you a probability and lets you stress-test different scenarios.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good success rate for retirement?

Most financial planners target 85–95%. A 90% success rate means your plan works in 900 out of 1,000 simulated retirements. Below 80% suggests the plan needs adjustment. Above 95% often means you are being overly conservative.

What standard deviation should I use?

For a 100% global equity portfolio, historical standard deviation is approximately 15–17%. For a 60/40 balanced portfolio, approximately 10–12%. For a conservative portfolio (40% equities), approximately 7–9%.

Does Monte Carlo account for inflation?

This simulator uses nominal returns and fixed nominal withdrawals. For an inflation-adjusted version, use your real return (nominal minus inflation) and your withdrawals in today's money.

How many simulations do I need?

1,000 simulations is sufficient for stable results. Running 5,000 produces marginally more precise estimates but the difference is small. The quality of your inputs matters far more than the number of simulations.

Why does my success rate change each time I run it?

Because the simulation uses random numbers, results vary slightly between runs. This is normal. The variation is small with 1,000+ simulations. Run it a few times and take the average if you want a more stable estimate.